PDA

View Full Version : VR-X / Tiptronic purchasing woe



MANiAK
02-10-2004, 04:02 PM
Greetings All,


I have recently been looking at a TJ VR-X 2000 model but im not sure what to expect from the tiptronic trans. :)

For starters my first thought was that it was slipping when i gutsd it, a mate tells me that its just the trans remembering 'driving style' ... (didnt sound like it remembered much RRRRRRRRNNG)

Secondly it didnt feel very fast at all, do the VR-X have any power increases, etc?


Any thoughts would be appreciated! :bowrofl:


On a different note, i dont want to start a car war but im curious what power/potential to expect from a 5 speed (VR-X) tiptronic setup! - I'm sure a bunch of you guys will jump in with 'get a manual ya fool' but if the difference is tolerable id much rather cruise with tiptronic right now


Thanks!

KoRRupT_1
02-10-2004, 10:42 PM
Did you check that Traction Control (TCL) is turned off before you thrashed it? It will probably cut power to the engine when it detects wheel slipage - probably the sensation you're experiencing....

Mine is a stock 2001 TJ VRX... first gear on triptronic is very very fast... sometimes there is so much power to the wheels that if i turn TCL off, i'm assured of leaving plenty of rubber behind when i slam the gas... Gear changes through the sequence is very smooth. There is definately a sweet spot at around 5000 rpm when it really punches through to just below redline.

You should expect around 163KW/5250rpm, 317Nm - according to Redbook.

As for comparison, the triptronics definately rocks - compared to auto's. Infact my fuel economy is around 11.2L/100km compared to 13.2K/100km on full auto when I drive like a 65 yr old retiree :)

I've dragged Falcon's AU XR6 & XR8's at lights and XR6 are piss weak... and XR8's well... I definately give them a run for their money... Even Commodore VX S are no match for a VR-X (appologies if i have offended)... so in terms of power, i think it's got plenty of guts for a 6 cyl... lucky for Magnas that it's got a nice big ass for the other drivers to look at when you pull away from the lights....:nutkick:

Any other VR-X owners agree?

Bain
02-10-2004, 11:01 PM
Any other VR-X owners agree?yeah somewhat.. except a VX S pack is just a Executive with a bodykit :) So of course you will beat it..

CanberraVR-X
03-10-2004, 04:38 AM
Mines sweet. The tippy is excellent. I leave it in auto most of the time.

First gear is very low... for good take offs.

Flava
03-10-2004, 06:37 AM
I was of the same opinion as you when i purchased my Sports. I thought if the difference is negligible i guess i'll tolerate it. I've regretted it ever since, i should have waited until i found a manual. Right now as matter of fact my car is in with Mitsubishi because my Tiptronic 'just died'. Automatic transmissions as a whole are fairly unreliable when placed next to their manual twins. I think you hit the nail on the head when you said 'get a manual ya fool'.
Thankyou, this has been 'My 2 Cents'

CanberraVR-X
03-10-2004, 07:10 AM
Sorry to hear that, Flava.

Do you get the auto fluid changed often? They reckon it goes a long way to preserving an a/t. twice as often as the book says. :)

MANiAK
03-10-2004, 07:29 AM
:shock:Oooh, could this be something that was fixed between series 1, 2 ??

Thanks for all your thoughts so far!
More would be appreciated!

sLug
03-10-2004, 11:13 AM
I have to agree with Korrupt_1 I have a tj sports(same running gear) and have expereinced this with traccy on never with it off, and there is a big difference between driving in d for drive and in tippy mode.As for what suits you it all depends on what you want if you wanted a cool street dragging car then i would suspect you would nt be lookin at a magna.I am happy with my car but if i was lookin for performance i would say the manuel but in reality it is only about .5 quicker over the quarter mile.And would spend the majority time normal driving which D for drive is excellent for if i am cruising through hills or want a fast take off i just use the tippy. :D :D And although it is a auto it still performs very well. :bowrofl:

The Sandman
03-10-2004, 04:08 PM
yeah.. sometimes I regret getting the tippy.. but not very often. I rarely use manual mode at any time other then tight corners ie. round-a-bouts.. almost never while accellerating. When i ran it at the drags, I used manual, just to get that extra 500rpm past redline out of her.. to beat a VS SS auto with exhaust, but that is about the only occasion.

The way I look at it, is that I spend 90% of my trip to work (40km) cruising in a staight line, where manual has no real advantage, but I had slightly more control then a standard auto when it comes to the windy bits. Plus it makes driving a whole lot easier with a coffee cup in my left hand :D
In short, if you want that race car feel, & are prone to thrashing, go manual. If you want comfort & ease of cruising, go tippy.

MANiAK
03-10-2004, 05:23 PM
Yup i _totally_ concurr!

I want a magna for a nice comfy car.

BUT occasionally its only right to "help" those (stereotypical) common***** drivers with their over inflated ego problems...:slap:

Always happy to help!



Forgive ones ignorance - but how does one turn of Traction Control?

I didnt notice a button in my short excursion in the car



Thanks for the feedback so far guys!

sLug
03-10-2004, 06:47 PM
Its the tcl button on the dash it is for trace & traction control. :D

BlackVRX
03-10-2004, 09:37 PM
I was in a similar state of confusion when I was buying my VRX. In the end it came to the fact that since I would be driving into the city a lot (Sydney) I couldn't stand the 1-2-1-neutral shuffle for an hour at a time so I went the tippy. Only very rarely do I regret not getting the manual but I figure I would be regretting not getting the tippy more often if I was sitting in peak hour traffic.

Most of the time I leave it in D but it is certainly nice to be able to go manual when you need it (burning off fords, falcons etc). It's the best of both worlds I reckon.

But really it comes down to personal choice. I've had absolutely not problems with the tippy but I know of at least a couple of members that have.

Good luck with your choice.

KoRRupT_1
05-10-2004, 06:57 AM
Forgive ones ignorance - but how does one turn of Traction Control?

I didnt notice a button in my short excursion in the car
Ignorance forgiven :doubt: :D

The TCL button is on the dash, just above the ignition key on the right hand side behind the steering wheel - near the dash light dimmer. It's a rectangular button with TCL printed on it. When pressed, a green TCL light should show up somewhere on the dash - indicating that TCL is now OFF - which means it's rubber burning time!!:badgrin:

Serriously, I think the tippy is a pretty good balance between comfort and performance. I'll never perform like a true manual, but atleast you can 'drink your coffee' while you're driving to work... It scores a 8/10 from me...

MANiAK
06-10-2004, 08:11 AM
Ah Gotcha's!

*mental note for the next test drive... switch to burn rubber mode :badgrin:*


Cheers fellas!


I think id be more than happy with tip-tronic!
Methinks i'll just start test driving both manual and tippy and wait for a real nice one!



Thanks again.. w00t

Altera98
06-10-2004, 04:26 PM
tippy auto is a buet compromise between comfort and relaxed cruising and having the control when u need it. BUT the autos cant take a lot of power thru them, so if u start developing the engines potential, u get to a point where the auto trans holds u up as the weak link. and u need to spend big $$$ to strengthen it.
this is my problem now, i cant use the full power without stressing the trans and causing slip on upshifts, the ecu then detects the slip and protects the trans by sending the tune into a "limp mode". and mine is only 3.0,
so if youre only planning to keep it stock or just minor mods the tippy is fine. :cool:

n0fy
06-10-2004, 05:45 PM
Are extractors classified as minor mods?

Altera98
07-10-2004, 12:19 PM
Are extractors classified as minor mods?

yes, it seems about 200kw gets too much for the trans.

Bain
07-10-2004, 02:12 PM
yes, it seems about 200kw gets too much for the trans.Thats a quote from Mitsubishi..

The tiptronics should beable to handle a bit more as you can select/hold the gears when changing..

MANiAK
07-10-2004, 08:40 PM
Mod restrictions!!! eek how rude!!!

How well do the manual boxes hold there own then???

Can we upgrade the tippy boxes?

That said... how many limbs will it cost? :doubt:


:redface:

Magna23
07-10-2004, 09:16 PM
any vrx owners dragged a supercharged s pak

Altera98
08-10-2004, 10:07 AM
Mod restrictions!!! eek how rude!!!

How well do the manual boxes hold there own then???

Can we upgrade the tippy boxes?

That said... how many limbs will it cost? :doubt:


:redface:

u only need to look at the turbo guys to see how tuff the manuals are! booya and mitsiman pumping 250-350kw through em... : :badgrin:

auto can be strengthened, around 1500-2000$ :cry: but if your planning a turbo to go over 250Kw then the manuals the only way.

MANiAK
12-10-2004, 06:43 PM
Aaaah fair enough.


Hmmm does anyone know anything about the gearbox and engine modifications made to the TJ models, ie MYO2 and SERIES II ?

Something to do with engine and gearbox im told... hmm

*continues googling*

MANiAK
16-10-2004, 05:32 PM
Well its time for a conclusion for this thread!

i bought myself a nice manual vr-x, 2001.

Only 30 clicks on it! wheeee



*waits patiently to collect it*

n0fy
17-10-2004, 10:05 AM
How much, if you don't mind me asking?
I'm looking for a 5 spd VRX atm.

MANiAK
17-10-2004, 02:18 PM
~20k
Good price? :D

n0fy
17-10-2004, 04:25 PM
FFS Why can't i find any at that price. All the ones I've found are around 23-24.
The salesman at Orix (VRX 80,0000 kms) wouldnt go any lower than $21,500. And there is no way I'm paying that much for that many Kms.

I'm actually considering getting a VT calais or charged S pack from the auctions if I can't find a manual VRX for a reasonable price within the next few weeks. :(

MANiAK
17-10-2004, 04:45 PM
:rant: Awww most salesmen are :nuts: i guess

I've been looking for a few months, its the first manual vr-x ive found so far! :badgrin:

every other car ive found was severely overpriced like the ones you found!


goodluck dude!


What state?

n0fy
17-10-2004, 05:04 PM
I'm in Vic but I'm fairly willing to travel interstate to purchase. I'm finding it damn hard without a car. Have to borrow work F100 or dads patrol, and the F100 isnt exactly small. lol.