What sort of alloys do you guys recommend?

I am sick of my hubcaps and would want something 16" up. Would 17" be too much?

Anyone selling any 16" or 17" that were fitted on a 2nd gen magna with tyres? I have 4 screws on the wheels, so I don't know if you can fit 5 screw alloys on mine.

You can get a set of 16's from a magna sports or verada fairly cheap.
You should have a 5 bolt pattern not 4 though.
But yeh i recommend from a later sports/verada model as the bolt pattern and offset etc. is exactly the same.