View Full Version : Quality of finish - Mags
BirdManVRX
26-02-2007, 04:31 PM
I was wondering if anyone has Advanti or Apec wheels or any other cheaper brand of wheels and have had them for a couple of years, what the quality of the finish is like now. Does the chrome or black painted bits start to peel or flake off. Do the machined lips loose their finish compared with more expensive brands.
I am looking at shadow/gun-metal/painted/machined wheels rather than straight silver.
Some of the stuff Bob Jane or Tempe tyres sells seem really cheap. Is it cheap for a reason ?
Can you give me example of actual experiences.
cheers
Righty
26-02-2007, 04:35 PM
From my experience when looking at buying wheels.. I was looking at chrome.
The cheaper brands sucked major ass, flaking and fading and all kinds of stuff. I ended up going for ROH, a while back a dinged my rim, right on the lip, and the chrome didn't even flake around the ding, or crack, or anything. just polish up the edges and you can't even notice it. I'm really happy with it.
Johnny Cash
26-02-2007, 04:42 PM
Unfortunately, rims are another one of those things where you get what you pay for...
There's a VERY good reason why you can pay anywhere as little as $1500 to as much as $6000 for a set of 18's and rubber. :redface:
dimi108
26-02-2007, 06:00 PM
Second hand Jap or European wheels are the best go. BBS, Enkei, Volks, Works, O.Z Racing etc.
The price of these second hand will cost as much as a brand new set of cheap tempe tyre/bob jane t mart wheels, but wheels are an important part of a car's dress up. So if you've got cheapies, others will think "errrr no taste" or "i've seen those wheels on a corolla" (let's not get started on zeneti 18" wheels. Oh my god :sick:) Plus the top brand and well known wheels are a lot lighter and a lot more durable, not to mention the extra street kudos hehe
Please consider buying some top wheels :D
If you're not sure on the brands, pm me and i'll give you a list of top jap/euro wheels to browse around for.
No cheapies!
Dimi - who loves a good set of wheels
D!GG3R
26-02-2007, 08:13 PM
Second hand Jap or European wheels are the best go. BBS, Enkei, Volks, Works, O.Z Racing etc.
The price of these second hand will cost as much as a brand new set of cheap tempe tyre/bob jane t mart wheels, but wheels are an important part of a car's dress up. So if you've got cheapies, others will think "errrr no taste" or "i've seen those wheels on a corolla" (let's not get started on zeneti 18" wheels. Oh my god :sick:) Plus the top brand and well known wheels are a lot lighter and a lot more durable, not to mention the extra street kudos hehe
Please consider buying some top wheels :D
If you're not sure on the brands, pm me and i'll give you a list of top jap/euro wheels to browse around for.
No cheapies!
Dimi - who loves a good set of wheels
so ur advising not to go to tempe cos thats were i was going to go for mine.
will3690
26-02-2007, 08:21 PM
I had APEC wheels on mi car for about 6 months. They were great, nothing wrong with them. I only sold them to upgrade to 19s
gremlin
26-02-2007, 08:26 PM
interesting the original poster is referring to advanti's as a cheap rim.. then someone else said enkie's are a good european brand.. enkie's and advanti's come from the same place :D
will3690
26-02-2007, 08:27 PM
interesting the original poster is referring to advanti's as a cheap rim.. then someone else said enkie's are a good european brand.. enkie's and advanti's come from the same place :D
Also to add, the APEC wheels are made in JAPAN!!! WAT!!!!! yer
dimi108
26-02-2007, 08:29 PM
Up to you chief. Tempe wheels aren't of best quality. If you're looking for bling bling chrome, then i guess tempe would be your one stop. But if you're looking for quality jap or race style wheels, shop around for some second hand top brand ones. Tempe specialise in chrome etc. but if you're looking for good set of euro/jap race or stylish wheels, then i suggest looking around :D
Tempe don't stock the reputable brands like Enkei, O.Z racing, Works etc. They have copy wheels. Like, their copy of Rays Gram Lights and AMG copies :sick:
Eg. Check out the pics. First one shows the originals. The second pic shows the fakies. The originals say "Volk Racing Wheels - Rays Engineering" on the spoke. But Tempe's ones says "Vork Racing Wheels - Ravs Engineering" in the same font! How embarassing if you're in traffic lights and someone spots them out. Ricer alert :rant:
And people actually buy them!! :nuts: They could've bought the originals in second hand condition for the same price. The originals are lighter and tough. And won't start peeling in the sun. Not to mention the top reputation of the genuine wheels. Plus I could bet these rubbish fakies weren't forged on a 50 tonne press.
So don't follow the crowd! Check out other places and look for some premium branded wheels. Best bet would be pre-loved ones!
dimi108
26-02-2007, 09:39 PM
lol Who said enkei's were european?
gremlin
27-02-2007, 06:25 AM
lol Who said enkei's were european?
sorry :cry:
I was wondering if anyone has Advanti or Apec wheels or any other cheaper brand of wheels and have had them for a couple of years, what the quality of the finish is like now. Does the chrome or black painted bits start to peel or flake off. Do the machined lips loose their finish compared with more expensive brands.
I am looking at shadow/gun-metal/painted/machined wheels rather than straight silver.
Some of the stuff Bob Jane or Tempe tyres sells seem really cheap. Is it cheap for a reason ?
Can you give me example of actual experiences.
cheers
Im not sure what youre classing as 'cheaper' wheel but Advanti arent cheap (unless they are selling discontinued rims)
I have a set of 19" Advanti's on my car and they have been the perfect model of quality (that i expected) since day 1.
Ive had them just over a year now, no cracks, no flakes (except the 1 rim i dropped on my wheel nuts), still shiny and smooth. Removing tar from the rim is easy and doesnt scratch the rim like lesser quality brands.
A few things about Tempe Rims:
Their chrome rims are plated (spray on) not dipped (prone to cracking/flaking). A true chrome dipped rim will cost in excess of $600 each!
Most of their rims use a very soft metal as there base (prone to warping/bending from pot holes etc) - The paint used to colour the rims is of poorer quality.
A guy at a dyno day had bought rims from Tempe and had em fitted just before coming to the meet.. When he put it on the rollers you could see one of his back wheels was warped.. (from Tempe direct)
Ive been over plenty of potholes and hard bumps that would fracture lesser quality rims.. The advanti's just keep on trucking on..
Looks for something unique.. Best bet is to look everywhere else but tempe as you can guarantee some ricer will have a set of 'quality tempe rims'
Damo_ooyar
27-02-2007, 11:00 AM
I have 18" ENIX rims on mine, apparently they are a cheaper brand of wheel... They are full chrome, Ive had em for the past 4yrs n not a single problem with them at all...when they are spotless they are brand new look
The other thing to consider with chrome is the plating. The 'splatter' spray stuff, when flaking, will flake and show the base metal.....= ghey. Proper chrome plating will be plated 2-3-4-5 times, so that even if a top layer does flake a little, theres still another 2 or 3 layers of chrome beneath it.
Anywho, with the finishes other than chrome, I don't think it matters as much (machined is machined). Generally the quality doesn't come down to the finish, its more the base rim style/quality and materials more than anything.
You get what you pay for.
Bob janes have some alright wheels in my book. Tempe....well....thats debatable.
G-Money
27-02-2007, 03:58 PM
I had APEC wheels on mi car for about 6 months. They were great, nothing wrong with them. I only sold them to upgrade to 19s
Yeah there on my car now :) nothing wrong with them still look great.
Thanks Will :)
BirdManVRX
27-02-2007, 04:04 PM
My basis for the "cheap" wheels comment, is with Advanti, Apec and RJR (Bob Jane) I can get a set of 17" wheels and tyres for under $1500. The rims themselves are an average of $200 each. Wheels like ROH or Speedy for the same size are around the $300-$350 per wheel. I know chrome costs more, but I'm not looking at chrome.
What category would you place the following:
Koenig
BSA
Speedy
CSA
ROH
As there are styles in these that I like.
My basis for the "cheap" wheels comment, is with Advanti, Apec and RJR (Bob Jane) I can get a set of 17" wheels and tyres for under $1500. The rims themselves are an average of $200 each. Wheels like ROH or Speedy for the same size are around the $300-$350 per wheel. I know chrome costs more, but I'm not looking at chrome.
As there are styles in these that I like.
What are the rims youre looking at from Roh and Speedy?
Some rims come in 2 or 3 peice design (which add to the price - and quality)
Speedy and ROH pretty high....BSA are below average. CSA average. Koenig....never seen
megatron
27-02-2007, 04:26 PM
Koenig
BSA
Speedy
CSA
ROH
Advanti
As there are styles in these that I like.
all the above brands are mid range price, quality will be above average compared too the cheap china copies
17" wheels and tyers can cost as little as $650-800 new
have a set of 20" advanti with polish rim and gunmetal grey spokes np at all
BirdManVRX
27-02-2007, 04:34 PM
What are the rims youre looking at from Roh and Speedy?
In Speedy I like 'Cheetah' and 'Envy MkII' (both 18's I know)
ROH I like 'Fury' and 'Vapour'.
Konig I like 'Unknown'
BSA I like 349, 334, 315, 291.
in the cheaper wheels I like:
RJR - 'Illusion', 'linear', 'Vogue', 'Chopper', 'Panther', 'Quake'
Advanti - 'Flame', 'Medusa', 'Havok' (same as RJR Illusion), 'Photon'
Is it any wonder I can't decide :nuts:
dimi108
27-02-2007, 06:30 PM
What category would you place the following:
Koenig
BSA
Speedy
CSA
ROH
As there are styles in these that I like.
Honestly ok,
Koenig: Got some nice designs but once again, it's a Tempe tyre wheel. Nope.
BSA: Piece of sh*ts copied Volks (Vork Racing) and O.Z Racing (B.Z Racing)
Speedy: Cheap. And crap. No thanks.
CSA: Nope. Cheap. Low quality. And see them on too many corollas and other riced up cars.
ROH: Good. Only good brand out of the lot. Nice designs and good wheel construction.
BirdManVRX
28-02-2007, 06:01 PM
So what do you think of this ROH wheel?
Reckon it would look alright on a white car ?
Damo_ooyar
01-03-2007, 06:18 AM
So what do you think of this ROH wheel?
Reckon it would look alright on a white car ?
I dunno bout a white car, but I reckon they would look pretty sweet on a dark green one ;)... Are the spokes a chrome or just a painted colour ?
useranth5532
01-03-2007, 07:36 AM
im assuming by 'koenig' you mean konig. thats not a tempe tyre wheel? in fact tempe makes copies of konigs....
[J3RK]
01-03-2007, 09:13 AM
mate has konig unknowns on has vrx, look great still going strong.
Righty
01-03-2007, 09:27 AM
In Speedy I like 'Cheetah' and 'Envy MkII' (both 18's I know)
ROH I like 'Fury' and 'Vapour'.
http://theweb.net.au/righty/2.jpg
Cheetah in black! MMmm :)
ROH Vapor in chrome can be seen on my avatar. Keep in mind if you're TE-TH they will stick out a bit in the front.. nothing too major, but you do notice it.. unless you have VRX flares.
GDImante
01-03-2007, 03:09 PM
i went looking at wheels yesterday after finding out the wheels i've already waited 2 months for will be another 8 weeks away (grr).
even looking at wheels from the same brand, the cheaper ones were obviously lacking in quality compared with wheels a little more expensive from same brand. especially evident on the machine finishing, the cheaper wheels had lots of machining lines and pitting in the clear coat, whereas the more expensive ones machine finish was smooth looked like chrome.
new wheels i'm looking at getting are $500 cheaper than the MAK (italian) wheels i was getting so hopefully not too crappy :-/
BirdManVRX
01-03-2007, 04:07 PM
Are the spokes a chrome or just a painted colour ?
I think they are machined.
im assuming by 'koenig' you mean konig.
Yes, I was pronouncing it as Koh-nig so I spelt it that way.
ROH Vapor in chrome can be seen on my avatar. Keep in mind if you're TE-TH they will stick out a bit in the front.. nothing too major, but you do notice it.. unless you have VRX flares.
I have pretty much decided on ROH Vapors. I was settled on the Shadow Chrome, but now seeing them in Chrome, I'm thinking hmm :drool: maybe. Dunno how they'd look on White. Not normally a fan of Chrome with white.
Can anyone recommend a place in Newcastle area that I can get 17x8 Vapors for less than $295/wheel ?
cheers
BirdManVRX
15-03-2007, 07:27 PM
OK I caved. I had to go the interest free route. I ended up at Bob Janes, and got a set of 17x7.5 RJR Illusions with Michelin Pilot proceda2's in 235/45/17. The tyres cost more than the rims, but they look great. I got a wider offset so they sit just inside the flares at the front. They look really good. Will get some pics up soon when I get a home while the sun is still up.
The thing I liked about what BJ did, is they painted my calipers black, fitted stick-on balance weights (out of sight) and chrome valve stems and caps without me having to ask. I am completely happy with their service.
Lucifer
15-03-2007, 07:40 PM
OK I caved. I had to go the interest free route. I ended up at Bob Janes, and got a set of 17x7.5 RJR Illusions with Michelin Pilot proceda2's in 235/45/17. The tyres cost more than the rims, but they look great. I got a wider offset so they sit just inside the flares at the front. They look really good. Will get some pics up soon when I get a home while the sun is still up.
The thing I liked about what BJ did, is they painted my calipers black, fitted stick-on balance weights (out of sight) and chrome valve stems and caps without me having to ask. I am completely happy with their service.
Interest free? Explain this concept to me... rims are next on my agenda...
BirdManVRX
15-03-2007, 07:44 PM
Interest free? Explain this concept to me... rims are next on my agenda...
You fill out a form, they enter it into the computer and GE money throws credit at you. Basically I got a line of credit, so I didn't have to pay a deposit, no repayments and no interest for 12 months. After that they can sell my children off for slavery, but the general idea is you save up and pay it out when the 12 months is up.
Lucifer
15-03-2007, 07:46 PM
You fill out a form, they enter it into the computer and GE money throws credit at you. Basically I got a line of credit, so I didn't have to pay a deposit, no repayments and no interest for 12 months. After that they can sell my children off for slavery, but the general idea is you save up and pay it out when the 12 months is up.
Thanks for clearing that up bro, sounds like a good idea for me and my... spending habits.
Oh and show us some pics! Can't wait to see them.
dimi108
15-03-2007, 07:49 PM
Yeah would love to check out the new wheels :)
Interest free for 12 months that's tops. Like a mini loan. How much were the wheels again did you say?
Mix_Master_Priz
15-03-2007, 10:58 PM
man no interest for 12 months is mad. i mite go check on BJ..in the market for wheels atm. got a quote the other day for ROH vapors in 19" shadow chrome (or watever their non chrome one is) $2720 with falkens on them 245/35/19. is that good/bad?
BirdManVRX
18-03-2007, 09:35 AM
Here are some pics. Unfortunately everytime I have had a chance to take some photos, the lighting or situation hasn't been great for a good shot. I hope these give a bit of an idea how they look.
spider-ken
18-03-2007, 09:54 AM
in my experience ROH are esaily the best of the affordable wheel brands. their quality is far above others in the same price bracket. i dont know if anyone is aware of it but they make nearly all the factory wheels for aussie built cars. if you check on the inside of your factory VRX alloy for example you will see a ROH stamp. same goes for falcons and commodores. they have been making factory wheels for many, many years, so i reckon they've got the runs on the board. also sometimes the expensive wheels eg.Enkei bring out a cheaper wheel brand with a new name to target a different market without cheapening the original name. these wheels are built to the same high standards they just dont have the "big name" branding on them. food for thought.:)
dimi108
18-03-2007, 03:47 PM
Hmm they look alright!
These new wheel designs are like 2 wheels in one. The black spokes and got the main silver ones. Looks like 2 wheels fused together :)
dimi108
18-03-2007, 03:48 PM
After that they can sell my children off for slavery.
HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA LOL :bowrofl: :bowrofl:
BR377
18-03-2007, 04:55 PM
Here are some pics. Unfortunately everytime I have had a chance to take some photos, the lighting or situation hasn't been great for a good shot. I hope these give a bit of an idea how they look.
Oh wow those are awesome, my cars white and ive been toying with the idea of some mainly black with a lil bit of chrome rims (seems to be the new craze) but was unsure of how it would look on a white car...
I got some money i need to blow and im hopeing for something similar to what you have, in about the 19" size :)
How much did they set u back?
mozzaldinho
18-03-2007, 05:49 PM
Here are some pics. Unfortunately everytime I have had a chance to take some photos, the lighting or situation hasn't been great for a good shot. I hope these give a bit of an idea how they look.
how much did that cost you, i have a white car and they look sick,
i love the black on white, white on balck what ever u want to call it look!
BirdManVRX
19-03-2007, 03:40 PM
how much did that cost you, i have a white car and they look sick,
i love the black on white, white on balck what ever u want to call it look!
They look a lot better than my crumby pics make them look. They make the car look much more aggressive.
The wheels with nuts etc cost around $190 a piece, the tyres were $215 each. All up with lock nuts and alignment, I got out of it for under $1,700. And I don't have to pay a cent until this time next year ..... GOLD !!
The Wheels are one of this month's specials at BJ. They are called Illusion and are 17x7.5. You can get the same thing from YHI (Advanti Havoc), but I think you'll pay around $215 per wheel.
BJ also have a similar wheel with wider polished spokes and only 5 black spokes called Chopper.
Powered by vBulletin™ Version 4.0.3 Copyright © 2016 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.